Re: Which version?

["Eric B. Ridge" <ebr@gazoo.tcdi.com>]

If we're actually taking a vote, I vote to have Paul Siegmann come back in
some form or another.

When ever we've had issues with GNUJSP or just "how do I do this with
GNUJSP" Paul has always posted his solutions.  He (and everyone else on
this list) has been great help and his GNUJSP does work well.

I'm not up to date on the new JSP 1.1 spec, but I hear there's a
development branch of Pauls's GNUJSP to add in XML and other features.  I
understand they're coming along nicely.  Maybe one of them can comment . .
.

again, I vote for Paul to come back . . .

eric

On Thu, 19 Aug 1999, Hendrik Schreiber wrote:

> Hi all!
> 
> In my mail yesteday I asked how many version there are. Well it seems
> that there are two - one by Paul Siegmann and one by Yaroslav
> Faybishenko. Yaroslav's seems to work, Paul's might be not working.
> Anyway - from looking at their sources and concepts I've got the
> impression that Yaroslav's implementation might work for now, but
> definitely needs some cleanup. Also it it probably very hard to extend
> in order to meet JSP 1.1 requirements like XML-support.
> I've got the impression, that Paul's vision of JSP is more advanced, his
> design clearer and better extensible. Therefore I'm quite sorry having
> to read that he wants to quit developing.
> 
> Couldn't you work together? Why did you, Yaroslav, start from scratch
> anyway?
> 
> Of course this easily written not having contributed myself...
> 
> I'm wondering what other people on this list think?!
> 
> -hendrik
> - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
>   The WebApp Framework        http://www.webapp.de/
>   jo!                 small&smart 2.1 servletengine
>   Persistence              objectrelational mapping
>   Java Server & Servlets    The German servlet book
> 
>